AI comparison : case of arc welding | AI-created blog with Ainan Kuma Farm

AI-created blog with Ainan Kuma Farm

This blog is created with AI and Ainan Kuma Farm.
Articles here MAY NOT BE based on my personal or official ideas.

Prompt:
Please explain the method of arc welding, touching on beads and spatter.
(Actually, prompted in Japanese meaning above and translated the response into English.(Except for the last response))

Response from ChatGPT 3.5
--------
Arc welding is a method of joining metals using an electric arc. Firstly, the parts to be welded are properly positioned, and suitable electrodes and welding materials are chosen. Next, the electrode is inserted into the welding machine, and the current is adjusted. When the current flows, electrons emitted from the electrode make contact with the welding material, creating an electric arc.

A bead refers to the weld bead formed on the surface of the welded parts during welding. The weld bead is a crucial factor that affects the strength and appearance of the weld. The shape and size of the bead vary depending on parameters such as the amount of welding material supplied and the welding speed.

On the other hand, spatter is the phenomenon where welding material or metal particles generated during arc welding scatter and adhere to the area surrounding the weld. Spatter can adversely affect the quality and safety of welding. To minimize spatter, proper current settings and mastery of welding techniques are necessary. Additionally, taking measures such as using shielding gases or anti-spatter agents is important when spatter occurs.
--------

Response from Google Gemini
--------
Arc welding is a technique that uses electricity to melt and join metals. Here's a simplified explanation of the basic steps and key points for achieving clean beads (weld seams) with minimal spatter (metal droplets).

What you'll need:
  Welding machine
  Welding rods
  Welding helmet
  Heat-resistant gloves
  Work table (vise recommended)
  Wire brush
  Hammer (for chipping)

Steps:
1.Preparation:
  Clean and grind the workpieces (metals to be joined) to remove dirt and moisture.
  Choose an appropriate welding rod thickness.
  Wear a welding helmet and heat-resistant gloves for complete safety.
2.Arc Initiation:
  Touch the welding rod to the workpiece to create an arc.
  Aim for an arc length roughly 1.5 times the diameter of the welding rod.
3.Bead Formation:
  Move the workpiece and welding rod at a steady pace to form the bead.
  The bead width should be approximately 1-2 times the welding rod diameter.
  Maintain the arc in the center of the workpiece for a stable bead.
4.Spatter Removal:
  After welding, use a wire brush to remove spatter.
  If necessary, use a hammer for chipping to improve the bead's appearance.

Tips for Beautiful Beads:
  Maintain a proper arc length.
  Move the workpiece and welding rod at a steady speed.
  Keep the arc centered on the workpiece for stability.
  Hold the welding rod at an appropriate angle (typically 15-30 degrees).
  Minimizing Spatter:

Set the correct current value.
  Choose a spatter-reducing welding rod type.
  Maintain a short arc length.
  Use a proper welding angle.

Additional Notes:
  Mastering arc welding requires practice. Start with simple projects.
  Prioritize safety by wearing proper protective gear.
  If unsure, seek guidance from experienced individuals or consult specialized resources.

References:

  Beginner's Guide to Welding Basics, Techniques, Procedures, and Types | WeldTool [Welding Equipment Store]
  https://weldtool.com/

  [Arc Welding Especially Recommended for Beginners] Let's Practice Together!!! #ArcWelding #Welding
  [https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=647l4K_PDkI]

  Arc Welding Basics (1)
  https://www.weldtool.jp/contents/beginner

Arc welding is a multifaceted skill. By mastering the fundamentals and practicing regularly, you can achieve beautiful weld beads. Don't hesitate to give it a try!
--------

Response from Microsoft Copilot (Japanese prompt and translated the response into English)
--------
Arc welding is a common method of joining metals by using an electric arc to melt the base materials and a filler material, which cools and solidifies to form a joint. The term “bead” refers to the deposited filler metal that has cooled and solidified after welding, typically appearing as a raised, wavy line. “Spatter” consists of small droplets of molten metal that are expelled from the weld pool and can adhere to the surrounding surface, potentially affecting the quality of the weld.

Here’s a simplified explanation of the arc welding process:
1.Set up the welding machine and ensure the correct current is established.
2.Strike an arc using a welding rod (or wire) as the electrode, touching it to the base material.
3.The heat from the arc melts the tip of the welding rod and the base material, creating a molten pool.
4.Move along the weld area slowly, adding filler metal from the welding rod to form the bead.
5.Adjust the angle and speed of the welding rod to minimize spatter.
6.In TIG (Tungsten Inert Gas) welding, spatter is minimal, allowing for cleaner welds. In shielded metal arc welding, the flux decomposes to form gases that protect the molten metal, reducing spatter.

Practicing arc welding is essential to develop a consistent bead width, height, appearance, and directionality. It’s also important to neatly finish the start and end points of the weld to enhance quality. With practice, you can learn to control spatter and produce smooth, uniform beads
--------

Response from Microsoft Copilot (Prompted in English)
--------
Arc welding is a fusion welding process used to join metal pieces. The basic principle involves using an electric arc to generate heat that melts the base material and a filler material, if used, to form a strong joint upon cooling. Here’s a brief explanation, touching on beads and spatter:

Beads:
In arc welding, a bead is the deposited material that forms the weld.
It’s the visible trace of the welding process, showing where the molten metal has solidified.
A good bead should be even and consistent, with a uniform width and height along the length of the weld.

Spatter:
Spatter refers to the small droplets of molten metal that are expelled from the weld pool during the welding process.
These droplets can scatter around the work area and stick to the base metal or surrounding surfaces.
Spatter is generally undesirable as it can affect the appearance of the weld and may require additional cleanup.

Arc Welding Method:
1.Safety First: Wear appropriate protective gear, including a welding helmet, gloves, and protective clothing.
2.Prepare the Metal: Clean the base metals to remove any contaminants like rust, oil, or paint.
3.Set Up the Equipment: Choose the right electrode, set the current on the welding machine, and prepare the work clamp.
4.Strike the Arc: Touch the electrode to the metal and quickly pull it away to ignite the arc.
5.Form the Weld Pool: Move the electrode along the joint to melt the base metals and form a molten pool.
6.Add Filler Metal: If using a consumable electrode, it will provide filler metal to the pool; otherwise, add filler rod as needed.
7.Control the Arc: Maintain a consistent arc length and travel speed to ensure a steady bead formation.
8.Minimize Spatter: Use the correct angle and speed of electrode movement to reduce spatter.
9.Inspect the Weld: After welding, check the bead for uniformity and absence of defects like cracks or porosity.

Practicing these steps will help you achieve a clean, strong weld with minimal spatter and a well-formed bead. Remember, controlling the heat and the speed of welding are key factors in minimizing spatter and achieving a good bead.
--------

Picture created with Microsoft Designer
--------

--------

Note:
Response for English prompt is more precise than that for Japanese prompt. Interesting.

日本語版はこちら

https://blog.kuma-farm-japan.jp/