Ruling Finds Liability for Power Harassment by Self-Defense Forces

 I (Sasamoto) am in charge of this case.

 

 The Japan Self-Defense Forces (SDF) harassed and bullied a disabled SDF member, who had difficulty walking due to surgery on his right leg, for 11 years, forcing him to climb the stairs to his room on the fifth floor. This former SDF member sued the Tokyo District Court for damages for violation of the National Compensation Law and the duty of care for safety; on March 14, 2024, the court ordered the government to pay 1.5 million yen in damages.

 

 The SDF attempted to prevent harassment by creating a consultation service for power harassment in 2018, and by tightening the criteria for disciplinary action for harassment. However, harassment within the SDF did not cease. As for sexual harassment, on December 12, 2023, the harassment against a member of Ms. Gonoi was found to be indecent and he was convicted of the crime. The harassment against the plaintiff in this case also took place between 2011 and 2020 and showed an insidious bullying nature. The harassment and harassment within the SDF is based on the SDF's organizational disregard for human rights.

 

 The ruling in this case identified the plaintiff's superiors, company commanders, as assistants in fulfilling the SDF's duty of care for safety, and found that they violated their duty of care for safety when they made the plaintiff climb the stairs to the fifth floor of his residence and prohibited him from owning a private car, without taking his physical disability into consideration. The court also found that the plaintiff was liable for damages for other forms of power harassment and bullying. This decision is significant in its criticism of the SDF's disregard for human rights.

Japan's Barriers to Refugee Status Still High

Updated: Feb 23, 2024

 

  In December 2022, an El Salvadoran filed a lawsuit against the Immigration Bureau's denial of refugee status to the Tokyo District Court for revocation, but the Tokyo District Court on February 2, 2024, also refused to recognize the refugee status.

 

 

 The ruling placed much of the burden of proof on the side of the refugee claimants, such as "there is no concrete evidence that they are being targeted by gangs," and the ruling repeated the defendant government's argument as it was without persuasive reasons for the denial of recognition. The case was immediately appealed.

 

 Japan's refugee recognition rate is unusually low compared to other host countries. Although the number of applicants exceeds 10,000 a year, only 1-2% are recognized as refugees. Japan's own narrow criteria for recognition, " specific and concrete fear of being persecuted," has been criticized but is still being adopted and followed by the courts. The " specific and concrete" criterion means that the applicant must be in concrete danger of being killed or arrested if he or she returns to the country, even though the social conditions in the country from which he or she fled are dangerous and there is a risk. For example, if the applicant already has a warrant out for his/her arrest and is at risk of persecution by the police or military, this is typical.

 

 However, there are many people who may be in danger of being harmed if they return to their home countries even if they are not in such danger. Can the immigration authorities and courts that have made the decision to send an applicant back to his/her own country be held responsible for his/her safety after returning home?

 2022年12月に、エルサルバドル人に対する入管の難民認定の不認定に対して、東京地方裁判所に取消を求めて提訴したが、2024年2月2日の東京地方裁判所も難民認定を認めなかった。

 判決では、「ギャングから狙われているという具体的な証拠がない」などと、難民認定者側に多くの立証責任を負わせ、不認定の理由を説得的に示さないで、被告国の主張をそのまま繰り返すに等しい判決だった。即時に控訴した。

 

 

 日本は難民認定率が他の受入国に比べて異常に低い。申請者数が年に1万人を超えているのに、難民と認定されたのは、ほんの1~2%にすぎない。日本独自の狭き認定基準である「個別具体的な迫害される恐怖」については批判されているが、いまだに採用し、裁判所も追随している。「個別具体的」基準とは、逃げてきた国の社会的情勢からして危険で帰国すれば殺害、逮捕などの危険があるにもかかわらず、その申請者自身に具体的な危険が及んでいなければいけないという基準で、例えば、申請者に逮捕状がすでに出ていて警察や軍隊から迫害される危険性がある場合が典型である。

 しかし、それほどの危険がなくても、帰国すれば危害を加えられる可能性がある人はたくさんいる。果たして、自国に帰らせるに等しい決定をした入管と裁判所は、帰国した後の身の危険について責任をとれるのだろうか。