Copilotに下記のように尋ねてみたところ、文法的に正しく自然だが、かなり堅く古い表現だとのことでした。
Does the following sentence sound natural to native English speakers: My profession is that of a dentist.
***************************************
Copilotの回答
Yes, it is grammatical and natural, but it sounds rather formal and old-fashioned in everyday conversation.
A native speaker would be more likely to say:
I am a dentist. (most natural)
My profession is dentistry.
I work as a dentist.
By profession, I am a dentist.
Your sentence, "My profession is that of a dentist," might be used in a formal written context, especially when contrasting professions:
Although my hobby is music, my profession is that of a dentist.
Without such a contrast, native speakers would usually choose the simpler "I am a dentist." So the sentence sounds natural enough, but it is more formal than most people would normally use.
*******************************************
そこで、さらに下記のように尋ねてみました。
Then, how about "My profession is a dentist?"
***********************************************
Copilotの回答
No. "My profession is a dentist" is not natural English, because profession and dentist are not grammatically parallel.
After "My profession is ...", native speakers normally use the name of a profession or field, not the person who practices it:
✅ Natural:
My profession is dentistry.
My profession is medicine.
My profession is law.
❌ Unnatural:
My profession is a dentist.
My profession is a doctor.
My profession is a lawyer.
If you want to refer to the person rather than the field, say:
I am a dentist. (most natural)
My profession is that of a dentist. (formal)
I work as a dentist.
By profession, I am a dentist.
The reason "My profession is that of a dentist" works is that "that of a dentist" means the profession belonging to a dentist, which matches profession grammatically. Without "that of", the sentence sounds odd because it equates a profession with a person.
****************************************************
実は、"My profession is a dentist"のような表現はよくある間違いらしく、たとえば、『1秒で攻略 英語の落とし穴大全』(小池直己・佐藤誠司共著)には下記の記述があります。
************************************************
彼女の仕事は獣医です。
× 1 Her job is a vet.
〇 2 She is a vet.
【解説】 〈S+ be 動詞(is/am/are) +C〉のCが名詞の場合は,S=Cの関係が成り立つ。S[仕事]= C[人]とは言えないから1は誤り。2(彼女は獣医です)はSもCも「人」だから正しい。これと同様の誤りは非常に多く見られる。
**********************************************
『1秒で攻略 英語の落とし穴大全』は、日本人が間違いやすいポイントがよくまとめられているので、一読することをお勧めします。
- 前ページ
- 次ページ