I just finished the first episode of the new Hanakimi live action.
It was....different. Where the Taiwanese version stuck pretty decently to the manga, you can tell in the first five minutes that this show will be a reinterpretation.
I'll admit that it took me a while to get into the pace of the show but, once I did, it was a good bit of fun.
Admittedly, I had my reservations about the seleciton of Oguri Shun for Sano, but in this new version's universe, he performs well, I think. Still not an amazing depth to the performance, but this is ドラマ so I don't really expect Emmy performances.
Horikita Maki's performance was delightful. She presented a spirited but not over the top Ashiya Mizuki. There was determination and strength as opposed to whinery and extravagence. So far, Maki wins best performance in the show.
I have to say that I wasn't too impressed with Ikuta Toma as Nakatsu. I imagine it's just the way the character is written, but the performance was too sullen for me, too angry. Nakatsu is one of my favorite characters, so I was a bit let down by this representation. Of course, it's only the first episode, so things could level out next week.
I don't know what the writers did to Nanba, but whatever their "vision" is, I don't like it. A suave, functional being was replaced by....something else entirely. I can't rate Mizushima's performance because I have no idea in the nine hells what the writers were smoking.
Still, the show was entertaining enough for me to watch it next week, and I'd probably watch the episode again with friends if they asked.
Final Rating: ★★★☆☆ Mediocre but Fun
It was....different. Where the Taiwanese version stuck pretty decently to the manga, you can tell in the first five minutes that this show will be a reinterpretation.
I'll admit that it took me a while to get into the pace of the show but, once I did, it was a good bit of fun.
Admittedly, I had my reservations about the seleciton of Oguri Shun for Sano, but in this new version's universe, he performs well, I think. Still not an amazing depth to the performance, but this is ドラマ so I don't really expect Emmy performances.
Horikita Maki's performance was delightful. She presented a spirited but not over the top Ashiya Mizuki. There was determination and strength as opposed to whinery and extravagence. So far, Maki wins best performance in the show.
I have to say that I wasn't too impressed with Ikuta Toma as Nakatsu. I imagine it's just the way the character is written, but the performance was too sullen for me, too angry. Nakatsu is one of my favorite characters, so I was a bit let down by this representation. Of course, it's only the first episode, so things could level out next week.
I don't know what the writers did to Nanba, but whatever their "vision" is, I don't like it. A suave, functional being was replaced by....something else entirely. I can't rate Mizushima's performance because I have no idea in the nine hells what the writers were smoking.
Still, the show was entertaining enough for me to watch it next week, and I'd probably watch the episode again with friends if they asked.
Final Rating: ★★★☆☆ Mediocre but Fun


Usually, I'm pretty pessimistic and, today, I think that's really making things worse on me. Stress doesn't get better by stressing about it - and all those fabulous, generally useless phrases.