Xin'an Evening News reported September 10 neuroblastoma cancer - an extremely rare malignant cancer, occurred in Fuyang 5 year-old female Tong Xiaojing body. Family everywhere,cinture louis vuitton, with the power of the media to raise a few million for charity. Unexpectedly,converse, this money led to a bizarre storm. The main members of this family are pulling into a pile lawsuit with the moral tone of an otherwise harmonious family into the diametrically opposed both the original defendant.
[Whole incident]
Wife sued her husband for her daughter's right to life. She believes that the donation husband,louboutin chaussures, father, her mother took the raise, but not to treat the child, watched the death of a child. Her husband denied his wife's allegations that the donation has been spent, he powerless. Recently, Fuyang City Yingzhou District court verdict, her husband a co-wife to pay the remaining amount 37,300 yuan.
7-year-old daughter suffering from a rare cancer
April 2007 day, Li Fangfang and 7-year-old daughter in military small quiet diagnosed with neuroblastoma cancer. That night, Li Fangfang thyself husband and father, her mother took the children rushed to the provincial hospital for treatment, and after a neuroblastoma tumor after resection, May 16,asics running homme, a small quiet discharged home. Since then, she will undergo a series of follow-up treatment costs a lot of money. Faced with high medical expenses unaffordable,cappelli miami heat, Li Fangfang an issue for help to the community and the media.
Reported by the media, a small quiet get a lot of social Donations. Li Fangfang mother very pleased. However, her husband and her in-laws suddenly stopped paying child's treatment costs.
Yesterday, the reporter saw in the alley poker Li Fangfang mother. The old lady said, son, and went to work, I do not know when to come back, his wife was not at home. "I never said no to the granddaughter of the doctor, but at home it is money." She said, when the pre-chemotherapy, is home to the full cost of raising all of the money goes to charity. His daughter after a court, the granddaughter of the late treatment has nothing to do with yourself.
In military defense counsel that, according to common sense, most people experience ill children, Zaguomaitie will give children to see a doctor, "but people do not like small quiet disease is too heavy, probably spent the money also incurable. "said the lawyer, the doctor's diagnosis conclusion is that changing bone marrow success rate of 50%, after the recurrence rate is 50%, and Anhui Province, currently only three cases of neuroblastoma cancer, had died before the two cases, only a small still a patient alive.
"Although doctors refractory disease, but did not say cure ah!" Li Fangfang that as long as there is a glimmer of hope, we must let the child live. The doctor told her that the child's body is currently in good condition, for further treatment, there is hope for a cure.
In addition, her husband and her in-laws' money, "saying, Li Fangfang disagree. "Money, not to mention there are two at home in Fuyang real estate, and even donated money to not spend the end." Li Fangfang said her husband's unit is good, income is not low in Fuyang, no money to treat the child, does not make sense .
The amount of money the couple uncompromising
Li Fangfang mother said, real estate is not his son, but his own, to sell the house to granddaughter treat things, not to mention to mention all. In this regard, in the military defense lawyers said in the home does have two properties, but they are small and old old house, not on the selling at high prices. In addition, the amount of money raised at home, saying the two sides are also inconsistent. Li Fangfang think there is more than ten million, her husband has said only a few million, early flowering is over.
The total number of small quiet get donations Visible clues from a series of reports in the local media.
"Hui Chong, general manager of real estate development company will be 3,000 yuan in cash handed the hands of the child's parents." (Yingzhou Evening News September 14, 2007)
"After the Golden Seed Group to help, through the group on the ground to understand the situation, plan this month (December 2007) about the 25th to hold a large-scale charity care activities in Fucheng, then, the Golden Seed Group was prepared to give not less than 30,000 yuan of wine, put money directly donated to charity caring little quiet. In addition, the bazaar scene also welcome the community to participate in Yijuan. "(" Yingzhou Evening News "December 15, 2007)
"Love from charity the scene, the reporter saw: national secondary actor Li Xiaoyong,christian louboutin paris, Anhui Province youth singer Nina, 罗广东 came to the scene, with their songs appeal to the community of caring people to lend a hand to save the little life donations. Activities from 9:00 until 17:00, a total of 5,000 yuan to raise funds. "(Fuyang People's Broadcasting Station 8 December 2007 report)
"Driven by the Agency (Fuyang CAA) led the global total voluntary contributions 6,730 yuan." "April 26, 2007, on behalf of the Commission initiative Wenfeng Kindergarten parents to small children quiet contributions, amounts as follows: 1. Kindergarten Parents contributions 15,gucci paris,600 yuan, a total of 4000 yuan donations kindergarten teacher,parajumpers vest, a total of 19,600 yuan. This process full record television reporter in "Tonight is" Play. "
In the late donations, according to a media March 22, 2008 reported: "Fuyang informed circles in a small quiet after illness, has held charity and donations and other activities, raising a total of nearly ten million yuan for medical expenses."
At this time, according to the proof presented by provincial hospital, a small quiet in the hospital medical expenses spent a total of 5 million yuan, and donated a small quiet father of digital media is not recognized. Since then, the small quiet parents to court, the court verdict is the result: a small quiet father contributions received, insurance claims and because a small quiet sick relief funds obtained receive subsistence allowances paragraph (remember paragraph to 2008 May), etc. meter 97,396.53 yuan,woolrich uomo parka, after deducting medical expenses to pay a small quiet and miscellaneous expenses meter 60,096.52 yuan,woolrich sito ufficiale, the remaining money is 37,ufficiale moncler,300 yuan.
The court sentenced her husband to return surplus funds 37,000
For the child's right to life, Li Fangfang when a person unable to support her husband and in-laws to court. Her lawsuit is the reason: her husband and her in-laws unjust enrichment.
The trial, the prosecution lawyers played recordings small quiet, small quiet cries echoed the court: "Dad, Grandpa, Grandma, help me, I really have no way, in the future I will repay you, I will honor you. "After listening to the recording, the defense lawyer, he said he felt shock and depression, crying.
Yingzhou District Court held that the right to life and health of citizens, small quiet get social care due to illness,ceinture burberry, his father and grandparents at the remaining donations amounted to 37,escarpin louboutin pas cher,300 yuan. 3 people which should be used to treat a small quiet,bvlgari bracelets, there is no legal basis to continue to occupy the paragraph,chaussure louboutin femme, is unjust enrichment, a small quiet now need the money to continue treatment, the father and other 3 remaining funds shall be paid in full. Since then, his father a small quiet suit seeks to go beyond the grounds of the judgment appealed, the mother is also a small quiet appeal.
August 14 this year, coordinated, simultaneous withdrawal of both parties, agreed to implement in accordance with the first instance. The judge said the parties in mediation, litigation money, might as well saved to treat the child. (Text characters are not his real name other than a solicitor)
[Social repercussions]
Donor: disappointed
Faced with her daughter's illness, Li Fangfang a man overwhelmed. The doctor said that follow-up treatment needs more than one hundred thousand yuan, after court, her husband cashed 20,peuterey wiki,000 yuan, Li Fangfang ED borrowed tens of thousands of their relatives and friends. As for the rest of the gap, Li Fangfang very dazed.
Those who have been with love for the small quiet quiet dedication, in the matter of development of deep disappointment, but also worried about the fate of a small quiet, and expressed concern for the future of a small quiet mother. Donations of good-hearted people who participated told reporters, when she saw her grandmother in a small quiet spot constantly bowed,hogan sito ufficiale, looking very poor, she would dig up 100 yuan, the old lady she even knock three heads. Donated money for the brother of a high also proved that donation site, a small quiet grandmother said all the money will be used to treat a small quiet. Member of the public said: "If I had known it like this,hogan sito ufficiale, I will not say what contributions."
Donors who think they have a right to know to donate to what purpose the money was sent. They also questioned: If ShouJuanZhe families who violated the donation wishes, whether they have the right to recover the donations
Ethicists: sigh
Fuyang Teachers College after an ethics expert about the incident, refer to "incredible." He believes that if the money does not give the child to see a doctor, is sit back and watch the death of another extreme disregard for life. The interests of the people over valued, and the extreme lack of moral conscience, so that some people go to extremes and become a pure egoist.
Fuyang City Women's Federation official said, and now her daughter had left a small quiet original home, the stranger in her family, she worried that the small quiet young age to see the best of human well-being, now do everything carefully, at her young psyche, should not bear such a heavy pressure. The person in charge, donations is to treat the child, if the unjust enrichment through donations, it should be brought to court for moral judgment.
Lawyer: Urgent legislative oversight donations
Anhui Hongda Lawyer Sen said that the development of the case is far beyond the scope of the law, become human nature and ethics of refraction.
Sen said that moral issues to be discussed, while the case exposed a legal question: When contributions to society after being in the hands of donors, who will supervise "case, the mother found her husband have a small quiet acts of unjust enrichment, prosecution to the court, maintains her daughter's legitimate rights and interests, but this is only the case. "Sen said that in most cases,moncler donna, if not donated one internal mutual supervision, outsiders can not know donation usage. Owned by its fundamental, Sen believes there are still gaps in the law in this area, should this legislation, a clear social contributions supervised party,peuterey outlet, in order to effectively safeguard the interests of donors. Anhui Daily
Disclaimer: This article represents only the personal views, nothing to do with Phoenix. Its originality, as well as in the statements and content without the site confirmed on this article and in which all or part of the contents, text authenticity, completeness, timeliness, without any guarantee or promise, the reader is for reference only, and please verify their own content.
相关的主题文章:
- http://www.chrisadamsperfumes.com/index.php?item/create_form/1
- http://store.shopping.yahoo.co.jp/ebest-dvd/0000001090665.html
- http://www.casebook.jp
- http://store.shopping.yahoo.co.jp/cio/d0802800002.html
- http://store.shopping.yahoo.co.jp/menscasual/n-tops-65-menscasual.html
- http://mizu-masa.sakura.ne.jp/yokkaichi/movie/sunbbs2/sunbbs.cgi?mode=form&no=2025&page=%22%22%22
- http://store.shopping.yahoo.co.jp/ichibankanshop/acd-78-6mf.html
- http://mizuki02.ciao.jp/cgi/diary/apeboard_plus.cgi/apeboard_plus.cgi?command=read_message&msgnum=30/\/