Substantial Assistance In Aiding And Abetting Matters Securities Lawyer 101 Go Public Blog On August 8, 2012, the Second Circuit clarified in SEC v. Apuzzo, 2012 WL 3194303, that substantial assistance in aider and abettor liability does not require proximate cause. The court determined that the Securities and Exchange Commission (the SEC) is only required to allege and prove that the aider and abettor associated himself with the venture in some way, that he participated in the venture as something that he wished to bring about, and that he sought by his action to make the venture succeed.The SEC filed a complaint alleging that Joseph Apuzzo aided and abetted securities law violations through his participation in a fraudulent accounting scheme involving his role as the Chief Financial Officer of Terex Corporation. The SEC alleged that Apuzzo was involved in fraudulent sale-lease back transactions created to allow another company, United Rentals, Inc. (URI), to recognize revenue prematurely and to inflate the profit generated from URIs sales.Apuzzos role included executing various agreements that disguised and concealed URIs continuing risks and financial obligations, and Apuzzo knew that URI was prohibited under GAAP from recording the revenue from these sales. Additionally, Apuzzo knew that inflated invoices from Terex were designed to conceal URIs indemnification payments to Terex.To be liable as an aider and abettor in a civil enforcement action the SEC must prove: (1) the existence of a securities law violation by the primary (as opposed to the aiding and abetting) party; (2) knowledge of this violation on the part of the aider and abettor; and (3) substantial assistance by the aider and abettor in the achievement of the primary violation.The district court granted Apuzzos motion to dismiss the complaint, concluding that the complaint did not meet the substantial assistance element of aiding and abetting liability it failed to properly allege that Apuzzo proximately caused the harm on which the primary violation was predicated. The district court held that the SECs complaint did not allege such proximate causation.On appeal, the Second Circuit reversed and found that the SEC met its burden, and that proximate cause was not an element of aiding and abetting in an SEC civil enforcement action. Specifically, the court found that,Cheap Nike Free Run Shoes, in SEC civil enforcement actions,nike free run 3, the test for substantial assistance is whether the aider and abettor in some sort associate[d] himself with the venture, that he participate[d] in it as in something that he wish[ed] to bring about,cheap nike free run 2, [and] that he [sought] by his action to make it succeed.The Court found that requiring proximate cause for aider and abettor liability in civil enforcement actions could release many aider and abettors from liability:Indeed, because only the SEC may bring aiding and abetting claims for securities law violations, many if not most aiders and abettors would escape all liability if such a proximate cause requirement were imposed, since, almost by definition, the activities of an aider and abettor are rarely the direct cause of the injury brought about by the fraud, however much they may contribute to the success of the scheme.This memorandum is provided as a general informational service to clients and friends of Hamilton & Associates Law Group and should not be construed as, and does not constitute, legal and compliance advice on any specific matter, nor does this message create an attorney-client relationship. For more information concerning the rules and regulations affecting the use of Rule 144, Form 8K, FINRA Rule 6490, Rule 506 private placement offerings, Regulation A, Rule 504 offerings, Rule 144, SEC reporting requirements, SEC registration on Form S-1 and Form 10, Pink Sheet listing, OTCBB and OTC Markets disclosure requirements, DTC Chills, Global Locks, reverse mergers, public shells, go public direct transactions and direct public offerings.